Your Cart is Empty
March 28, 2024
To Princetonians for Free Speech Subscribers, members and friends,
This month PFS spotlights an exciting event on campus. On April 22, a new film, The Coddling of the American Mind, based on the best-selling book of the same name by Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff, is showing on campus as part of a college campus national tour. See below for details.
We are eager to hear what you think of this newsletter and our other communications, so if you have a minute please fill out our subscriber survey if you have not yet done so.
And consider joining our Inner Circle for insider-only events with students, guest speakers, and our founders.
One of PFS’s main goals is to bring to campus and support events in collaboration with student or other groups that discuss the importance of free speech and academic freedom, or that model open discourse. Here we announce an important upcoming event, followed by information about two recent events.
On Monday, April 22, The Coddling of the American Mind, a recently-released feature documentary based on the best-selling 2018 book of the same name, will be presented as part of a US college campus tour. Hosted by Whig-Clio in collaboration with PFS, a live panel discussion and Q and A with award-winning filmmakers and journalists Ted and Courtney Balaker will follow the showing. Through the eyes of students from different universities, the film reveals how group-think, fear of cancellation, and race and gender-based orthodoxies that dominate campus life contribute to intellectual and emotional fragility, and undermine a university’s core mission of knowledge-seeking in a culture of free and open debate. The novel decision to release the film on Substack has been a success so far, and the campus tour is drawing big crowds of students. Watch the Official Trailer, and visit the movie’s Substack to learn more about the film and the campus tour. For those of you in the Princeton area, time and venue details will be announced soon.
Lost in the Chaos: Immanence, Despair, and the Political Idols of the Age. On March 26, 2024, PFS collaborated with Princeton’s student Federalist Society chapter to bring to campus R.J. Snell, author and Editor in Chief of Public Discourse and Director of Academic Programs at the Witherspoon Institute, who spoke about his book of the same name.
On March 20, 2024, the student group Veritas Forum, in collaboration with PFS, presented Secularism, Faith and the Future of Liberal Democracy, a conversation between Joseph H.H. Weiler, University Professor, NYU School of Law, and Robert P. George, McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence, Princeton University.
Universities as Mediators, Not Partisans
By Howard Sereda *78, Princeton Alumni Weekly, March 22, 2024.
College Presidents are Oblivious to their Campus Climate
By Samuel J. Abrams, Minding the Campus, March 18, 2024 (See quote of the month below.)
2024 Survey of College and University Presidents
“Inside Higher Ed’s 2024 Survey of College and University Presidents was conducted by Hanover Research. The survey included 380 presidents from public and private nonprofit institutions, for a margin of error of 4.66 percent. The survey included questions on such issues as campus speech, public perceptions of higher education, race on campus, artificial intelligence, general financial and economic confidence, and mental health.”
America’s Elite Universities are Bloated, Complacent and Illiberal
Posted by ACTA, March 7, 2024, the article appeared in the Economist on March 4, 2024.
Why Intellectual Diversity Requirements on Campus Won’t Work
By Princeton Professor Keith E. Whittington, The Dispatch, March 13, 2024
UC Delays vote on much-debated proposal to restrict some faculty speech
By Michael Burke, Ed Source, March 20, 2024
The Skeptics were Wrong Part 2: When it comes to free speech, the college kids are not alright.
By Greg Lukianoff and Sean Stevens, The Eternally Radical Idea, Substack, March 21, 2024.
A book by social psychologist and NYU Professor Jonathan Haidt, co-founder of Heterodox Academy and co-author with Greg Lukianoff of The Coddling of the American Mind, has just been released. Parents, school teachers, college professors and administrators, and everyone concerned with the health of American youth should read it. The book is more than a sounding of the alarm, it is a call to action. In his data-rich analysis, Haidt shows that starting around 2012, rates of depression, anxiety, loneliness among children and teens start shooting up. By 2015, most girls are on instagram with unlimited data plans, and teachers can’t keep phones out of the classroom. Among girls his data shows that self-harm is rampant, and especially in the lower end of the income spectrum, boys are consumed by video games and online porn. “Phone based childhood has replaced play based childhood. … This is not a place where human children can grow up.” But Haidt is hopeful: “Everyone sees it in this generation. No one disagrees. We just need to have parents overcome their feeling of resignation…. We are going to win, this is the year for phone-free schools.” Purchase the book HERE.
The past five months have shown the world just how toxic speech is on college campuses. The climate for open inquiry and dialogue is under attack nationwide, and students are scared to speak, question, and express themselves freely. Using disparaging rhetoric, even violence, to prevent speech is now commonplace on campus, and thus, many students are turning inward, and genuine liberal learning is being interrupted. Yet, most college presidents believe their campuses are perfect examples of viewpoint diversity.
The 2024 edition of Inside Higher Ed’s survey of college and university presidents sadly reveals that many higher education leaders are oblivious to the issues of free speech on their own campuses. This should give anyone interested in the state of our colleges and universities pause. The 2024 survey captured the voices of 380 presidents, 206 from public and 174 from private institutions. While presidents remain hopeful for the future of their schools, they clearly are unaware of what is happening outside their very offices....
Nearly 82 percent of college and university presidents rate the climate for open inquiry and dialogue on their campus as ‘good’ or ‘excellent.’ 92 percent of presidents who have been in charge of their institutions for 10 or more years rate their campus’s dialogue as ‘good’ or ‘excellent.’ …
Oddly enough, when these leaders were asked about open inquiry in higher education generally, just 30 percent of collegiate presidents believed that the climate for open inquiry and dialogue in higher education generally is good or excellent. And . . . presidents with 10 or more years at their current institution . . . rate the overall collegiate speech climate poorly -- just 21 percent agree that it’s ‘good’ or ‘excellent.’ …
Samuel J. Abrams, excerpted from “College Presidents are Oblivious to their Campus Climate”, Minding the Campus, March 18, 2024. A copy of the survey is available at Inside Higher Ed.
Thank you for your interest in our newsletter and our website. Please forward our newsletter and/or a link to our website to others who might be interested, or suggest that others subscribe directly HERE.
And please spread the word in your class notes! We want more Princetonians to know about PFS. Just email pawnotes@princeton.edu to submit your note.
Of course, we welcome your comments and suggestions HERE.
For more national and campus news concerning free speech, academic freedom and related topics, please visit our website HERE and be sure to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
To Princetonians for Free Speech Subscribers, members and friends,
This month PFS turns a spotlight on the faculty movement at America’s private elite universities, and we urge President Eisgruber to endorse and lead this growing movement.
We are eager to hear what you think of this newsletter and our other communications so if you have a minute please fill out our subscriber survey if you have not yet done so.
And consider joining our Inner Circle for insider-only events with students, guest speakers, and our founders.
To Princetonians for Free Speech Subscribers, members and friends,
First, an exciting announcement: PFS has just launched an Inner Circle program. For just a minimum annual donation of $100 you can join our PFS Inner Circle and will receive access to insider-only virtual and in-person events including virtual cocktail hours with our founders, current students and special guests, invitation-only reunion receptions, and honorary insider gifts, with a bonus gift for subscribers over $500. Please fill out the form at the link below to join!
December 18, 2023
To Princetonians for Free Speech Subscribers, members and friends,
The chaos on elite university campuses since the massacre in Israel on October 7 has been a wake-up call. Presidents of Harvard, University of Pennsylvania and MIT answered questions by the House Committee on Education during what is now the most viewed hearing ever. It revealed lawyer-prepped obfuscation and the glaring double standards that are the norm in higher education on free speech protections. Donors and trustees forced the resignation of Penn’s president Liz Magill and its board chair Scott L. Bok. Harvard’s board came out in defense of President Claudine Gay while many called for her ouster. Alumni and donors are realizing the true nature of the institutional transformations of their alma maters’ core principles and are demanding change. This is no surprise to us: For three years PFS has watched and reported on this transformation at Princeton and at other universities throughout the country. Join us to keep informed and learn more.
