Commentary: Right Deed, Wrong Reason

December 11, 2023 1 min read

Heather Mac Donald
City Journal

Excerpt: Liz Magill was forced to resign Saturday as president of the University of Pennsylvania—by all indications because, at a congressional hearing, she could not bring herself to declare that calls for the genocide of Jews are punishable speech. She would more justly have lost her job for being a bald-faced hypocrite when it comes to campus free expression. The future of higher education depends on which of these motives governs such decisions in the future.

The presidents’ refusal to declare hypothetical calls for the genocide of Jews punishable conduct has been portrayed as the greatest scandal of the hearing. It was not. The real scandal was the presidents’ duplicity in citing a “commitment to free expression” as the reason why they needed to give “wide berth to . . . views that are objectionable,” as Gay put it.

Click here for link to full article

Leave a comment


Also in National Free Speech News & Commentary

Commentary: The global free speech recession

October 30, 2025 1 min read

Matthew Harwood
FIRE 

Excerpt: Since Charlie Kirk’s murder, the Trump administration has launched a blitzkrieg against Americans’ free speech rights. The scale and speed are dizzying — and they jeopardize the United States’ credibility as the world’s leading defender of free expression as other democracies continue to falter.

Being critical of America, capitalism, and Christianity shouldn’t put you on the feds’ radar because all those viewpoints are protected speech. A federal investigation should only occur when there’s reasonable evidence that some person or group — regardless of their constitutionally protected beliefs and opinions — has crossed the line into criminality.

Read More
Are Too Many Professors Excellent Sheep?

October 30, 2025 1 min read

Amna Khalid and Jeffrey Aaron Snyder
Banished, Substack

Excerpt: Amna & Jeff talk to Jon Zimmerman about why some profs are afraid to speak their minds.

Read More
Harvard Salient’s Editor Says Conservative Student Magazine Will Not Obey Suspension by Alumni Board

October 29, 2025 1 min read

Samuel A. Church and Cam N. Srivastava, Crimson Staff Writers
Harvard Crimson

Excerpt: Harvard Salient editor-in-chief Richard Y. Rodgers ’28 announced on Tuesday that the conservative student magazine would remain active despite a Sunday statement from its board of directors suspending its operations pending a conduct investigation.

Rodgers wrote in an email to the Salient’s mailing list that the board’s decision to temporarily halt its operations was “an unauthorized usurpation of power by a small number of individuals acting outside the bounds of their authority.”

Read More