“Discard [Library] Books … That Reflect Gender, Family, Ethnic, or Racial Bias"

Eugene Volokh September 19, 2024 1 min read

Eugene Volokh
Volokh Conspiracy, Reason Magazine

Excerpt: Next week, the entire en banc Fifth Circuit will be hearing Little v. Llano County, a case involving allegations of viewpoint-based book removals in a public library. As I've noted before, the Supreme Court has never resolved whether such removals are unconstitutional. Pico v. Bd. of Ed. (1982), which considered the matter as to public school libraries, split 4-4 on the subject, with the ninth Justice, Justice White, expressly declining to resolve the substantive question.

I'm not sure what the answer here should be. I tentatively think a public school is entitled to decide which viewpoints to promote through its own library: School authorities can decide that their library will be a place where they provide books they recommend as particularly interesting/useful/enlightening/etc., essentially as supplements to the school curriculum (over which the school has broad authority).

Click here for link to full article

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in National Free Speech News & Commentary

A National Call to Action to University Presidents and Governing Boards
A National Call to Action to University Presidents and Governing Boards

Linda E. McMahon, Secretary of Education  August 06, 2026 1 min read

For the good of the Nation, university leadership must seize this occasion to drive essential reforms—a process some began by adopting positions of institutional neutrality and improving policies related to campus protests. Before the end of 2026, I call on every postsecondary institution to describe to the American public your commitments to rigorous teaching, pathbreaking research, and national service—commitments that make our universities a bedrock institution of the American republic.

Read More
New Compact Shows Resistance Works, but Fight for Higher Ed Isn’t Over
New Compact Shows Resistance Works, but Fight for Higher Ed Isn’t Over

Todd Wolfson and Randi Weingarten August 06, 2026 1 min read

Now the administration is back with Compact 2.0, formally titled "A National Call to Action to University Presidents and Governing Boards." It includes some rhetorical flourishes intended to make it seem less threatening to teaching, learning and research. But make no mistake: It once again asks colleges and universities to align themselves with a far-right agenda at the expense of students’ education and the public’s well-being.

Read More
‘Radical Reform’: Trump Official Explains New Plan to Get Colleges to Change
‘Radical Reform’: Trump Official Explains New Plan to Get Colleges to Change

Francie Diep  August 06, 2026 1 min read

Read More