PRINCETON FREE SPEECH NEWS

EXPLORE COVERAGE >

NATIONAL FREE SPEECH NEWS

EXPLORE COVERAGE >

Why Are College Students Still Celebrating Charlie Kirk’s Murder? Campus Culture Has Normalized Political Violence

Why Are College Students Still Celebrating Charlie Kirk’s Murder? Campus Culture Has Normalized Political Violence

Tal Fortgang
’17

A year after Charlie Kirk was murdered at Utah Valley University, campuses are still full of people who have unusual views of violence—especially political violence. Students still treat political killing as a joke, at worst, and an understandable response to their opponents, at best.

On September 23, at a Turning Point USA “Pick Up the Mic” event at the University of Texas at San Antonio, a student who called herself “Pamper Baby”—later identified as Isa Casahuga, 19—stepped up to conservative activist Christian Collins and recited a parody of “’Twas the Night Before Christmas” she had written mocking Kirk’s assassination.

’Twas the night before the Kirkiversary / And all through the house / Not a creature was stirring / Not even a mouse / The flags were hung proudly / the memes all on deck / as we solemnly remembered a shot to the neck.

The crowd applauded. Collins asked if she was happy with herself. Casahuga answered: “Baby, I’m thrilled.” She then told Collins he was brave to appear without a neck brace. Collins said he would pray for her.

The University of Texas System, once the clip went national, announced it would not tolerate “the incitement of violence” and would respond “consistent with applicable state and federal law and university policies.” The poem likely does not amount to incitement, though the comment about the neck brace is conceivably a true threat. In any case, this is not about legal repercussions, but about the unabashed, smirking celebration of a man’s untimely death.

What would compel Casahuga to make a mockery of a man being shot to death—publicly and proudly? What did she think she was doing?

First, she was performing for a campus audience, using vernacular that she assumed her classmates would smirk at: “Kirkiversary,” the memes, the in-joke about a neck. Around the anniversary, Georgetown students floated a Charlie Kirk lookalike contest on the anonymous app Fizz. Mysterious “Kirkaversery” flyers at the University of Tennessee–Knoxville advertised a gathering to “celebrate the first new year AK (After Kirk).” Casahuga was on-trend.

Second, she has learned that just about anything is acceptable if you are “punching up” at the powerful. To her, Kirk was not a husband and father murdered in front of everyone. He was Power: white, male, Christian, MAGA, “hate.” Casahuga was raised in the generation taught that bullying is the worst thing that a person can do, and empathy (or kindness) is its opposite. Yet she ended up a bully. In her calculation, she was being empathetic to those who deserved it: the people victimized by Kirk’s bullying. Celebrating a bullet to the bully’s neck is the supreme act of solidarity with the voiceless. It is kindness—to a generation that never learned what kindness is, and confuses it with fighting The Man.

She has absorbed the lessons of an activist culture, one that has emphasized kindness while stripping the term of all moral imperatives. This flourishes on campus because universities have spent a decade teaching people like her that words against the right people are violence, and violence against the right people is speech.

FIRE’s Greg Lukianoff has been emphasizing the statistical findings showing Casahuga is no outlier. “30% of students say violence to stop a campus speech can be acceptable, at least in rare cases. And 69% say the same about shouting down speakers.” This doesn’t mean “students love murder,” but it does mean that some reorganization has gone on in students’ minds. Violence, which to most college students is theoretical and abstract, has been normalized as a speech act. To those students, Kirk’s killing was the equivalent of a far-off war being fought between two abstractions.

Indeed, it parallels how students react when they invest foreign conflicts with contrived moral meaning. As I chronicled in City Journal, across the country Students for Justice in Palestine chapters commemorated October 7 by celebrating the perpetrators. Like those who celebrate Kirk’s murder, they are clearly not antiwar or antiviolence. Theirs is a pro-war stance, even a pro-atrocity stance, if the atrocities are punching up at the powerful. This suggests that perhaps the students’ moral system is off kilter. At one campus, for example, the SJP chapter celebrated “the Palestinian resistance … eliminating over 1,100 settlers” as “anti-imperialism … in its highest form.” Entire families burned alive? They were just “settlers.”

Yet during the encampment years, elite media ran public relations for them. The Associated Press, Reuters, NPR, CNN, PBS, and the Washington Post all described the students as “anti-war protesters.” These are self-deceiving lies. Viewing the students as heirs to the campus protests of the 1960s and 1970s allows elites to dismiss them as foolish young ideologues or romanticize them as noble voices for peace. They are young ideologues, all right. But their ideology is horrid.

American adults picture undergraduates as Vietnam-era sentimentalists—naïve, kind, allergic to body bags. That picture is fifty years out of date, if it ever was true. These students are idealistic. Their ideal is not peace. It is righteous cruelty: violence that “gives voice to the voiceless,” “defends the powerless,” or otherwise lands on a designated oppressor. They do not want everyone to get along. They want the right people to lose, and while most of them would not kill or maim directly, they will usher their movement along in other ways—through speech, symbols, and gatherings that demonstrate their ascendancy and command legitimacy.

We can say two things at once, neither of which universities are very good at saying themselves. Free speech means Casahuga may speak. A grotesque poem is not incitement merely because it is vicious. Civilization, however, means the rest of us must call her ethic, and SJP’s, what it is. This is not compassion, peace, or ordinary politics. It’s an ideology driven by bloodlust and justified by bespoke ideas about social justice. It is foreign to most Americans, thankfully, but it is growing. It has found a home on campus because campuses have provided it with fertile soil.

Tal Fortgang ’17 is a Legal Policy Fellow at the Manhattan Institute, a regular contributor to PFS and a contributing writer at The Dispatch.

 

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.