Commentary: Fair Admissions and Fair Assessments

By Joshua Katz and Solveig Gold July 03, 2023 1 min read

By Joshua Katz and Solveig Gold
American Enterprise Institute

Excerpt: Last week’s Supreme Court ruling in Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College is the latest salvo in the war over what one might call the merit of “merit.” With many colleges already ditching quasi-objective metrics like SAT scores on the grounds that such tests are racist, the focus—thanks to one line in the Chief Justice’s opinion—is now squarely on admissions essays, the evaluation of which is evidently subjective. It’s hard not to worry that, despite SFFA’s admirable efforts, the admissions process is about to become even less fair.

How is student performance most fairly evaluated? The question plagues not just admissions officers but educators everywhere.

Leave a comment


Also in National Free Speech News & Commentary

The Limits of Trust
The Limits of Trust

Jason Steffen April 09, 2026 1 min read 1 Comment

Admiral Andrew Cunningham once said of the British Royal Navy, “It takes the Navy three years to build a ship. It will take 300 years to build a new tradition.” Gaining trust is harder than breaking it, and public trust, in particular, should not be trifled with. Over the last decade, trust in science, and academia more generally, has eroded substantially, partly if not largely due to internal problems.

Read More
The Real Crisis in Higher Education Isn't Just Ideology, It's Faculty Decline
The Real Crisis in Higher Education Isn't Just Ideology, It's Faculty Decline

Samuel J. Abrams April 09, 2026 1 min read 1 Comment

Observers across the political spectrum have identified a real problem in American higher education: too many campuses have drifted from genuine inquiry toward ideological performance and political engagement. That diagnosis is not partisan. It reflects a widely shared concern that universities are prioritizing critique over inquiry, activism over scholarship, and signaling over substance.

But even that diagnosis is incomplete - and the missing piece matters enormously for how we respond. A quieter, more structural crisis is unfolding beneath the ideological one: the erosion of faculty pay, stability, and dignity. Until we take that seriously, we will keep treating symptoms while the underlying condition worsens.

Read More
DeSantis signs Florida law to label groups as terrorists and expel student supporters
DeSantis signs Florida law to label groups as terrorists and expel student supporters

Associated Press April 09, 2026 1 min read 1 Comment

Gov. Ron DeSantis signed a measure into law Monday that gives him along with other Florida leaders the ability to label groups as domestic or foreign terrorist organizations and expel state university students who support them.

The law, criticized by free speech advocates, allows a top official at the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to designate a group as a domestic or foreign terrorist organization, with the governor and three other members of the Florida Cabinet approving or rejecting the designation.

Read More