Commentary: Fair Admissions and Fair Assessments

July 03, 2023 1 min read

By Joshua Katz and Solveig Gold
American Enterprise Institute

Excerpt: Last week’s Supreme Court ruling in Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College is the latest salvo in the war over what one might call the merit of “merit.” With many colleges already ditching quasi-objective metrics like SAT scores on the grounds that such tests are racist, the focus—thanks to one line in the Chief Justice’s opinion—is now squarely on admissions essays, the evaluation of which is evidently subjective. It’s hard not to worry that, despite SFFA’s admirable efforts, the admissions process is about to become even less fair.

How is student performance most fairly evaluated? The question plagues not just admissions officers but educators everywhere.

Leave a comment


Also in National Free Speech News & Commentary

The Rise of Civics Centers at America’s Universities
The Rise of Civics Centers at America’s Universities

December 18, 2025 4 min read

There is a growth sector in American higher education. The number of “Civics Centers” has exploded in the last decade, and especially since 2021. 

What are these civics centers, and what explains their proliferation now? 

Heterodox Academy (HxA), the leading non-partisan higher education reform organization in the US for faculty, staff and students, championing open inquiry, viewpoint diversity and constructive disagreement, has decided to provide some answers.

Read More
Demagogy or Pedagogy? A Better Way to Approach Antisemitism on Campus
Demagogy or Pedagogy? A Better Way to Approach Antisemitism on Campus

December 18, 2025 1 min read

In February of this year, a few colleagues and I co-founded a group called Concerned Jewish Faculty & Staff (CJFS), which now has more than 200 members on more than two dozen campuses. Our group, which is predominantly made up of academics at Massachusetts colleges and universities but includes members from across New England, is one of several such efforts nationwide that have coalesced into a new National Campus Jewish Alliance. 

We recognize that Jewish safety is inseparable from the safety of all people, and we work to foster academic environments that reduce antisemitism by treating educators as partners, not as suspects.

Read More
Snapshots of Censorship: ‘It’s Only 3 or 4 Words’
Snapshots of Censorship: ‘It’s Only 3 or 4 Words’

December 18, 2025 1 min read

Read More