


What happened
Michel Houellebecq, widely considered France’s most important living novelist, is under criminal investigation for comments he made about Muslims in a 2022 interview. After a complaint from the Union of Mosques of France, a judge in Nanterre opened a case against him for “complicity in incitement to discrimination, hatred or violence.”
Houellebecq is best known in the US for his 2015 novel Submission, a dark satire about France giving way to Islamist rule. His 2022 comments, like the novel, gave a bleak view of where he thinks France is headed. Many readers will find them harsh. That doesn’t make them a crime.
A tale of two writers
A recent Wall Street Journal column compares Houellebecq’s case with the 1989 fatwa against Salman Rushdie over The Satanic Verses. Back then, writers and free speech groups in the West rallied to Rushdie’s defense without hesitation.
“Back in the day, it took an Ayatollah to indict a writer for offending Islam. … Now it only takes a Western European government.”
Today, the author argues, the reaction has been very different.
“From PEN America and most other literary confabs, there has been no peep of protest.”
One exception is PEN Berlin. The German group acknowledged that people can reasonably debate whether Houellebecq’s remarks were fair or offensive, but it was clear about the principle at stake:
“A warning about violence is not an incitement to violence.”
Why this matters here
Free speech protects ideas people disagree with, or it doesn’t mean much. The same instinct that drives a government to prosecute a novelist drives a campus to shout down a speaker or punish a student for an unpopular opinion. When free speech groups stay quiet because the speaker is unpopular, they weaken the principle for everyone, including students and faculty at Princeton.
“Without free speech, without the free exchange of ideas, even rude ones, we will not long remain what we have been.”
Leave a comment
Comments will be approved before showing up.