Harvard Law Professor Cass Sunstein Delivers Free Speech Lecture on Constitution Day

By Marisa Warman Hirschfield ‘27 October 03, 2024 2 min read

By Marisa Warman Hirschfield ‘27

“Universities should follow the First Amendment, period. That’s it. That’s the framework.”

Legal scholar Cass R. Sunstein shared this message with over a hundred people in McCosh 50 during his “Free Speech On Campus” lecture. The James Madison Program hosted Sunstein, a Harvard law professor, on September 17th in celebration of Constitution Day. Attendees received a free copy of Sunstein’s 2023 book How to Interpret the Constitution upon entering. Adults comprised most of the audience with some undergraduate students scattered throughout the lecture hall. I attended in my capacity as a ’24-’25 Writing Fellow for Princetonians for Free Speech, an alumni group that offers many opportunities for student involvement.

Sunstein emphasized that the First Amendment is a solid foundation to underpin universities’ free speech policies. “Building a building from the ground up is really hard and people are going to disagree about how many doors and how many windows. To say, ‘we are following the first Amendment’ makes life far more manageable.”  

He maintained that his proposition is not as simple as free speech absolutism. Universities occasionally must enforce content-neutral restrictions if speech impedes upon their educational mission. Some of these restrictions, he explained, are simple and unobjectionable. Universities need not tolerate speech that is unprotected by the First Amendment. Speech must pass the “clear-and-present-danger test”–that is, if speech is likely to incite imminent lawless action, it should not be allowed on college campuses.

There are also gray areas. Whether speech poses a threat to a university's educational mission can be equivocal. According to Sunstein, this is where First Amendment law is least developed.

“There are going to be hard cases where the educational mission will be arguably, but only arguably, incompatible with certain forms of humiliating, degrading, or frightening speech. Reasonable people can differ there.”

He shared an example: “If a math professor believes that men are better than women at math and that women can’t handle the subject, there’s a good argument that he can be directed not to say that in class, on the grounds that if he does so, he will not be able to do his job.”

Despite restrictions being necessary on occasion, Sunstein underscored that “free speech should get the benefit of the reasonable doubt.” As arsenals of democracy, Sunstein argued, “America’s universities should permit members of their communities to say things that are jarring, disruptive, disturbing or, to some, enraging. The best response to errors and offensive and horrifying speech is more speech, not punishment.”

Sunstein’s speech lasted an hour and was followed by a Q&A segment, facilitated by Robert George, Director of the James Madison Program.

Sunstein left his audience with a final wish: “Freedom ought to ring on public streets, in public parts, and on campus. What universities don’t need is the unanimity of the graveyard. They need noisy and teeming pluralism, the teeming pluralism of living communities that are trying to figure out what’s true.”

Marisa Warman Hirschfeld ’27 studies History and Creative Writing and is a Princetonians for Free Speech Writing Fellow

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in Princeton Free Speech News & Commentary

Princeton and peers soften opposition to attacks on higher education in graduation speeches
Princeton and peers soften opposition to attacks on higher education in graduation speeches

Devon Rudolph  September 03, 2026 1 min read

Since the start of President Donald Trump’s second term, top colleges and universities have faced an onslaught of federal attacks: slashing grant money for research, pressuring schools to end diversity, equity, and inclusion programs, cracking down on visas for international students, and ending graduate program sponsorship for active duty military at top schools. However, some Ivy League universities — the center of many of Trump’s ongoing attacks — have decreased messaging on the potential consequences of these federal directives.

“One thing that’s been clear is that a lot of universities have felt that publicity would bring no advantage or do them no good,” history professor David Bell GS ’91, who has been outspoken about federal actions against universities, said in an interview with The Daily Princetonian.

Read More
A Princeton Professor’s Advice to Young Conservatives
A Princeton Professor’s Advice to Young Conservatives

Robert P. George  August 27, 2026 1 min read

As a professor who is known to dissent from progressive ideologies that are dominant at universities such as Princeton, where I’ve taught for nearly 40 years, I’m frequently asked by students for advice about how to navigate a campus they worry will be hostile to them. Some are pro-Israel, or politically and socially conservative, or religiously observant.

They fear being treated unfairly by faculty members who are hostile to their beliefs. Many are afraid of being regarded as outcasts by their more liberal or progressive peers. They worry about being excluded from academic opportunities or not treated equitably in social or other extracurricular activities. To these students I say, with regret: You’re right to worry. I’ve seen these things happen.

Read More
Why some colleges are banning AI in the classroom — and why that's a good thing
Why some colleges are banning AI in the classroom — and why that's a good thing

Tal Fortgang August 27, 2026 5 min read

Universities may be tempted to treat these capabilities as inevitable improvements in education. Students will be able to consume vast amounts of information, more than ever before. But like AI writing itself, such consumption would be vast but shallow. The more interesting possibility, then, is that AI will force universities to rediscover the value of intellectual work that cannot be outsourced.

Read More