What the Manhattan Statement Gets Wrong on University Reform

John Tomasi  July 21, 2025 1 min read

John Tomasi 
Heterodox Academy 

Excerpt: Last week, the Manhattan Institute issued a statement on university reform, calling on the “President of the United States to draft a new contract with the universities.” Many of the signatories hold university and faculty appointments. Two days after the statement was issued, UATX President Carlos Carvalho responded with a forceful endorsement of the statement, which has led to controversy that has already prompted the resignation of Lawrence H. Summers from that institution’s board of advisors.

The Manhattan Institute statement’s recommendations for university reform are not novel; in fact, they are similar to a number of the reforms HxA recommended last month in our Open Inquiry U Reform Agenda. But there are important distinctions between the two reform agendas that must be explicitly called out.

Click here for link to full article 


Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in National Free Speech News & Commentary

Trump Administration Can’t Cite Changed Priorities to Terminate Grants
Trump Administration Can’t Cite Changed Priorities to Terminate Grants

Ryann Quinn July 22, 2026 1 min read

When university researchers started to receive notice last year that the Trump administration was canceling their grants, they often didn’t get a clear explanation why beyond that their project “no longer effectuates agency priorities.”

Read More
New Academic Freedom Podcast on Pernell Decision
New Academic Freedom Podcast on Pernell Decision

Keith E. Whittington  July 22, 2026 1 min read

A new episode of the Academic Freedom Podcast has been released. The podcast is sponsored by the Academic Freedom Alliance and the Center for Academic Freedom and Free Speech at Yale Law School.

Read More
Bans on “Divisive Concepts” Risk Stifling Speech
Bans on “Divisive Concepts” Risk Stifling Speech

Erin Shaw July 22, 2026 1 min read

The growing (though not unanimous) acknowledgement that academia has lost public trust may be increasingly uncontroversial. But identifying remedies to repair that broken trust is proving to be much more contested.

Read More